Friday, 4 April 2014

Not just for kids: comics are maturing - David Thorpe

Considering that I seem to be the only contributor to this site with an interest in comics I regard it as an obligation to pass on anything inspirational I come across to broaden the appeal of this amazing artform.

There are many books that act as an introduction to comics and graphic novels. A new one has just come out that is a worthy contribution to this list. It's written by an old pal of mine, Paul Gravett, who has single-handedly carved out a unique career for himself as the British go-to expert on anything to do with comics and been called by The Times "the greatest historian of the comics and graphic novel form in this country", which is absolutely true.

The book is called, appropriately, Comics Art, and published by Tate (the art gallery people, so it really is about art). The thing about this book is that you will hardly find any American Marvel or DC superheroes within its covers. And if you think that is all there is to comics, you're in for a big surprise. Even if you know Raymond Briggs, Hergé, Art Spiegelman and Marjene Satrapi  as comics authors and artists you'll find a treasure trove of other gems herein.

Did you know, for example, that it took a panel of experts many days to decide together when the first comic was produced? The occasion was a comics festival in Italy in 1989, and the panel decided upon an issue of a newspaper strip from Sunday, 25 October 1896 in the New York Journal called The Yellow Kid, because, amongst its characteristics, was the first use of speech balloons, together with a series of linear 'panels'.

This is a shame, because I thought I owned an earlier 'graphic novel', an English translation of Mr Oldbuck's Adventures, dating from around the 1880s, but in this instance there are no word balloons, just pictures with a caption beneath them telling the story.

The book examines all the different ways in which artists have been and are continuing, particularly nowadays, to stretch the possibilities of a medium that has really come of age: trying to use visual imagery instead of language to convey emotions such as Lighter Than My Shadow by Katie Green, about bulemia, messing around with associations, as with Seth's George Sprott, or playing around with the subjectivity of time passing, as with Pebble Island by Jon McNaught.

Paul is especially astute when analysing the political aspects, whether intended or not, of comics. For example, in a discussion of stereotypes in comics, he looks at ways in which comics have been used both to promote and to subvert stereotypical prejudices.

Perhaps the most courageous example of this is by Gene Yang, who challenged the offensive image of the buck-toothed Chinese stereotype and turned it to positive use as Cousin Chin-Kee, a satire of "the worst racist prejudice".

Paul looks at graphic reportage such as Ukrainian Notebooks by the Italian artist Igort, who spent months in that country unearthing stories about the famine engineered in 1932-3 by Stalin to enforce his farming collectivisation programme in which tens of thousands died. No wonder many Ukrainians now do not want to be part of Russia.

There has also been a massive trend recently for autobiography in comics which some feel has been overdone and itself has been subverted by a spoof autobiography (Momon by Thomas Boivin et al. masquerading under the name Judith Forest).

Artists are still extending the vocabulary of comics. One of my favourite examples which Paul quotes is Asterios Polyp by David Mazzuchelli, who not only introduces different typography and balloon shapes for different characters but messes around with different artistic styles for the characters at times in order to give further expression to their different points of view. Further, he deliberately limits his palate to blue and red (and their combinations) to enforce his creativity.

You can read Comics Art just by looking at the pictures and obtain a fantastic overview of the sheer creative possibilities of comics for telling stories of every particular kind.

Comics are not a genre, they are a medium like the novel or the film, and every conceivable type of genre has been tried within the medium. They are peculiarly subjective, just like reading a book, but reaching out to more senses and more associations in the mind of the reader.

I first met Paul when we worked together on a magazine with the unfortunate name of Pssst! back in the early 80s: we were both on the editorial committee and I was a contributor. Later, with his and Peter Stanbury's Escape imprint, he published some of my stories. Meanwhile he was amassing the most extensive library of graphic novels I have ever seen.

God knows how many he has now, but he has curated many shows and knows everybody who is anybody in the medium and industry, yet remains forever modest. This is a truly informative, inspiring and intelligent book.


Penny Dolan said...

David, you may be the only one on this site enthusing about comics, but that doesn't mean we don't want to hear about comics, or learn about more than Captain Marvel and the obvious names.

Keep sharing your good insider and expert knowledge. It's all very much appreciated! Thanks!

David Thorpe said...

Glad you like it, Penny! I will, don't worry....

John Dougherty said...

You're certainly not the only contributor to the site with an interest in comics, David - but you're probably the only one with any real expertise in the area. So thanks for this, and keep sharing!

Dianne Hofmeyr said...

I'm passing this on to a friend in South Africa whose son is a graphic novel artist. The blog is fascinating David and is particularly right for now when so many people are turning to graphic novels. I was surprised at how much shelf space is taken up by them at my local library. Shows they are being taken seriously.

Richard said...

You're preaching to the choir here, David. I'd add some old favourites to your list, the first two which were turned into movies with the same success as books generally are -- they became pale shades of the original:
V for Vendetta, which includes the superb This Vicious Cabaret which was missing from the movie because almost every subject it referenced had been cut. And yes, the comic includes the music.
The Watchmen -- Which misses out the parallel, incredibly dark story being read in a comic within a comic.
The Ballad of Halo Jones -- When the going gets tough, the tough go shopping.

Joan Lennon said...

These look amazing - and challenging! Thanks for posting!

David Thorpe said...

@John, you bet I will;

@Dianne, in my neck of the woods most of the graphic novels in libraries are Marvel, DC or manga, & not much of the rich diversity hinted at in Comics Art. Library buyers should be more courageous! There is so much more but you probably need to visit a serious comics shop to find them.

@Richard; I too love the books you mention and could tell a few stories about their creation, as I witnessed it first hand, as desk editor or pal of the creators, but these are the very well known instances from the '80s, all written by Alan Moore, which gave rise to the Titan Books slogan dreamt up by Igor Goldkind, their publicist at the time: 'the comics have grown up'. Yes they had, but it took a while for publishers to do anything but put out the odd 'serious' book. Most flooded the market with overpriced repackaging of earlier serialised material which often walked out of shops under people's jackets because they couldn't afford them. It took a while for the market to recover from this and for an abundance of non-SF/superhero fare to emerge from the hands of the kind of creators mentioned in this book.

BTW I should mention that Paul has curated the current show at the British Library: Comics Unmasked: Art and Anarchy in the UK - Go see if you're in town!