Wednesday 18 October 2023

Rethinking The Hag - by Lu Hersey

 When you think of the word 'hag', what image does it conjure in your mind? The wicked, nightmare crone of fairy tales, probably. But in reality, throughout most of history, by my age I'd be classified as a hag. It's a word defined by most dictionaries as 'an ugly, old and unpleasant woman'. Only a reasonably supportive bra and good modern dentistry saves me (and even then, I probably fit the bill). 

During the notorious witch trials, a high proportion of the women strangled and burnt at the stake as witches were simply old, post-menopausal women. Toothless and wrinkly, no longer of any interest to men, unable to easily support themselves financially, and often with only a cat for company. Ostracised by society, they were more likely to voice their opinions freely (the modern version would be giving fewer fucks). Frankly, I fit at least two of those categories. I'd have been strangled and burnt, for sure.


Even today, old women garner very little respect in society. No matter what knowledge or wisdom they've gained from being around for so long, they don't look great, and they're largely ignored. It's still OK to treat them with contempt. I recently read former gynaecologist Adam Kay's autobiography, This is Going to Hurt - in which he devotes at least half a chapter to his intense dislike of doing operations on older women, in detail. No sensitivity reader needed, apparently. Old women, like people with ginger hair, are still apparently fair game for society's derision and snide remarks.

Of course old men don't look great either, but far fewer were burnt as witches simply because they were cantankerous, old and ugly. No one derides them for having age related prostate problems or wrinkly old bollocks. And they can still garner respect for some reason, however nasty they might be. Look at Rupert Murdoch. 

Anyway, to get to the point - isn't it time we change society's attitude to old women? We need to portray a society where old women aren't all blood-thirsty, embittered old hags who want to cook children and render their fat down to make mysterious potions. (Although I wouldn't want to entirely exclude this kind of activity - after all, it is coming up to halloween.) But we need positive portrayals in children's stories, alongside the evil hag. Include old women simply as people who've been around a long time and have seen a great deal - who might even be able to tell you something life changing. A nugget of invaluable information that transforms your future. Whatever. I try to include at least one in every book I write.

And that's the end of my rant for today. Now pass my broomstick, I'm going out.


Lu Hersey

https://www.patreon.com/Writingthemagic

twitter: https://twitter.com/LuWrites

Blue Sky: https://bsky.app/profile/luwrites.bsky.social


3 comments:

Andrew Preston said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ms. Yingling said...

Hurrah! Well said! I, too, am just some decent dentistry away from being a hag. In schools, many people retire when they are about my age, so students don't see a lot of older people. Keep spreading the word. As I like to tell my students "Old age and treachery will always beat youth and exuberance"! (David Mamet)

Polly said...

Yup, I'm not old by our standards, but I'm totally hag-age in pre-dentistry eras, I give fewer and fewer f**ks every year, and I am a married lesbian with four cats and three rats. Totally a burn subject.